Four Ways to Keep Your EV Battery Pack Cool
What cooling methods are there and what are the advantages and disadvantages of each method?
Maintaining the correct temperature range of your electric vehicle battery pack is essential for battery performance and longevity. What cooling methods exist and what are the pros and cons of each method? We explain it in this article.
Air cooling
How does it work?
By letting air flow through the battery pack, you can cool batteries. For example, Nissan uses this technology to cool the batteries of the Nissan Leaf. They let the air from inside the car circulate through the battery pack. With this system, the batteries can be cooled, but also heated during cold winter days.
Cons
A disadvantage of this system is that the temperature of the air in the vehicle is also the temperature at which the batteries are cooled. If you turn up the heating in the car because you are cold, the batteries are also heated. This is sometimes not ideal, especially when a lot of power is required.
Alternative
Another way to cool the batteries with air is to channel outside air into the battery pack in the vehicle. In this case, the temperature of the batteries will fluctuate with the outside temperature fluctuations. During hot summer days, the temperature of the batteries will also increase. This is again a problem for high-power applications, as the risk of battery overheating increases.
When is it suitable?
In most applications with low to medium power air cooling is sufficient. The power demand of the drivetrain is not that high, so the battery temperature remains around the ambient temperature. Even when high power is demanded occasionally, air cooling will still be sufficient because the batteries have more than enough time to cool down after a short period of high power demand.
When the power demand increases, the air cooling system will no longer be sufficient. Let's look at some other types of cooling systems.
Liquid cooling
How does it work?
Liquid cooling is the most popular way to cool a battery pack. A liquid cooling system consists of many more components than, for example, an air cooling system. These components make it possible to improve the cooling performance by upgrading the components.
Electric vehicle manufacturers like Tesla and Audi use liquid cooling in their battery packs. This cooling system is a separate cooling system that only the battery pack cools. The motor and controller are cooled with a second liquid cooling system due to the temperature differences between the components. The battery pack must remain below 60 degrees Celsius, which means the temperature of the coolant must be kept as low as possible. The temperature of the motor and controller can reach up to 140 degrees Celsius.
When these three components share the same cooling system, the battery pack is heated by the motor and controller. A separate cooling system for the battery pack is necessary.
When is it suitable?
Liquid cooling is the preferred solution for almost every battery pack. Whether it is a low or high power application, liquid cooling has the most advantages. In low power applications, you can take care of the battery pack so that it always operates at the right temperature. In high power applications, you can cool the battery pack to the maximum. You want to keep the temperature of the cooling system as low as possible to allow maximum power for the longest possible time.
In addition to all these cooling benefits, you can also heat the battery pack by adding a heating element to the cooling system.
As mentioned before, the cooling system of the battery pack and the cooling system of the motor and controller should be separated. These two cooling systems can be combined occasionally to heat the battery pack with the motor and controller when needed. Tesla for example uses this method. They can heat the battery pack with the heat generated by the motor and controller. This is very useful during cold winter days.
Cooling with heat-conducting materials
How does it work?
Heat conducting materials, such as heat pipes, can be used to extract heat from the battery pack. This is a slower way of cooling than when using liquid cooling. Metals such as aluminum and copper are also heat-conducting materials.
Cons
Unfortunately, this method of cooling is only a part of the cooling system instead of a complete system. When you use this as the only cooling system, the thermally conductive material must be very large. The thermally conductive material has a certain heat capacity. This is the amount of heat a material can absorb per weight. For a large extraction of heat from the battery pack, the thermally conductive material would have to be massive.
This means that you have to combine this way of cooling with another cooling system, like the two systems mentioned earlier. The heat conducting material will lead the heat to the other cooling system.
Immersion cooling
Another way to cool a battery pack with liquid is to immerse the entire battery pack in the coolant. This technology is already used in the world of supercomputers.
Cons
This method is very expensive. Another disadvantage is that the amount of liquid used has a certain heat capacity. As explained earlier, this is the amount of heat that a material can absorb. By immersing the entire battery pack in a liquid, the liquid can only cool as much as its heat capacity allows. In other words, the liquid heats up together with the battery pack. The liquid only slows down this process.
When is it suitable?
In high power applications, you will need to combine this cooling method with other types of cooling systems. For example, the housing can be made of aluminum, which conducts heat very well. When air flows past this housing, the battery pack and the liquid inside can be cooled.
Choosing the right cooling method for your electric vehicle can be quite challenging. At Power Battery, we are developing a unique cooling method for high-power battery packs. Feel free to contact us if you have any questions about your project or request a consultation.
Tailor-made advice for your EV project
Choosing the right cooling method for your electric vehicle can be quite challenging. At Power Battery we develop a unique cooling method for high power battery packs.
Please feel free to contact us if you have any questions about your project or request a consultation.